Monday, November 4, 2013

Social Sciences and the Humanities

I came across this interesting article the other day, about universities and the humanities:

They have generous compensation, stunning surroundings and access to the latest technology and techniques of scholarship. The only thing they lack is students: Some 45 percent of the faculty members in Stanford’s main undergraduate division are clustered in the humanities — but only 15 percent of the students.
With Stanford’s reputation in technology, it is no wonder that computer science is the university’s most popular major, and that there are no longer any humanities programs among the top five. But with the recession having helped turn college, in the popular view, into largely a tool for job preparation, administrators are concerned.
“We have 11 humanities departments that are quite extraordinary, and we want to provide for that faculty,” said Richard Shaw, Stanford’s dean of admission and financial aid.
The concern that the humanities are being eclipsed by science goes far beyond Stanford.
I wonder if the inclusion of weirdo "social sciences" under the humanities umbrella has anything to do with declining enrollment. These days, people want JOBS when they get out of school. Education is too expensive to pad your transcript with Womyn's Studies or Being Gay in the 21st Century.

Some professors are incorporating the current generation's tether to technology to garner interest in their fare:

At Stanford, digital humanities get some of that vigor: In “Teaching Classics in the Digital Age,” graduate students use Rap Genius, a popular website for annotating lyrics from rappers like Jay-Z and Eminem, to annotate Homer and Virgil. In a Literary Lab project on 18th-century novels, English students study a database of nearly 2,000 early books to tease out when “romances,” “tales” and “histories” first emerged as novels, and what the different terms signified. And in “Introduction to Critical Text Mining,” English, history and computer majors use R software to break texts into chunks to analyze novels and Supreme Court rulings.
Yep, being proficient in Rap Genius will land you a killer-good job. Or not.

I'm glad to see schools concentrating on STEM fields, but I think that every college graduate should have an basic understanding of philosophy, literature, art, and languages. What do you all think?


6 comments:

  1. When I read the writings of our founding fathers, I'm mesmerized by their insights and their understanding of history. Those guys were truly EDUCATED.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed.

      They were humbled by the thought that while the then current king of Great Britain was something of a tyrant and they could no longer abide living as his subjects, the concept of the anointed sovereign did in the long run serve to limit the power of the state. And republics had intrinsic weaknesses. So they looked to history and learned the best they could. They did a pretty good job...

      Delete
  2. "English, history and computer majors use R software to break texts into chunks to analyze novels and Supreme Court rulings."

    FYI, "R" above is a programming language used in statistics and business / financial / scientific analysis. As well as linguistic.

    "Critical Theory" is BS but if they're doing analysis with R, well, power to them; at least someone is learning.

    But: "lies, damn lies and statistics" + "big data" (which is just statistics on steroids) -> "big damn lies"...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I wonder if part of the problem with the "humanities" is that haven't the classics been all but abandoned and replaced by modern crap?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, in my very limited experience, it depends on who is teaching the class. I had an excellent teacher for philosophy; he stretched my brain until my head hurt, then stretched it more. He presented opposing points of view without adding in his personal bias or snark. It wasn't until the class was nearly over that I found out he's a Baptist minister.

      I took geography too, for one of my electives. It was horrible. It was 100% social justice crapola. In the text book, there were a few pages about stratification and types of rocks. The rest was global warming and whining about wealth distribution. Bleh.

      Delete
  4. When my son was in elementary school, the big thing was "consolidated math" or something like that. I thought it sounded interesting until I saw the text book. A word problem would go something like this:

    "Fred could cut down five tress in one day. Charlie could cut down four trees in one day. How many species would be extinct at the end of one week."

    ReplyDelete