Thursday, July 4, 2013

Round-Up of International Reactions to the Military Coup in Egypt

I saw this on Al Jazeera this morning and wanted to pass it along as I think it will be of more than passing interest to you all.  I considered tossing the EU entry out, as EU statements make the U.S. State Department seem a bastion of strong stances, but kept it in in the interests of letting foolish institutions appear foolish.  Note the response of the U.S. and our major allies.  Of especial interest is the view of the President of Syria.

European Union

The EU has called for a rapid return to democracy in Egypt.

EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton said: "I urge all sides to rapidly return to the democratic process, including the holding of free and fair presidential and parliamentary elections and the approval of a constitution, to be done in a fully inclusive manner, so as to permit the country to resume and complete its democratic transition,"

"I strongly condemn all violent acts, offer my condolences to the families of the victims, and urge the security forces to do everything in their power to protect the lives and well-being of Egyptian citizens."

Saudi Arabia

Saudi King Abdullah sent a message of congratulations to Adly Mansour ahead of his appointment as interim president.

"In the name of the people of Saudi Arabia and on my behalf, we congratulate your leadership of Egypt in this critical period of its history. We pray for God to help you bear the responsibility laid upon you to achieve the ambitions of our brotherly people of Egypt," the message said.

Turkey

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's Islamic-rooted government, which had formed an alliance with Morsi, spoke out in favor of the ousted leader. Turkey's foreign minister slammed the overthrow as "unacceptable" and called for Morsi's release from house arrest. Turkey itself was hit last month by a wave of protests against Erdogan's perceived authoritarianism and attempts to impose his conservative views on secular society.

Iran

Iran was disappointed at the fall of Morsi, with a prominent legislator saying the leader failed to reshape Egypt's powerful military and other security agencies. After Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution, the new leadership formed military and security forces loyal to the clerics and others. Morsi's government had ended more than three decades of diplomatic estrangement with Iran dating back to the revolution, when Egypt offered refuge to Iran's deposed shah.

Tunisia
The ruling Islamists in Tunisia, the cradle of the Arab Spring, condemned the overthrow as a "flagrant coup". Ennahda party leader Rachid Ghannouchi expressed astonishment, saying the overthrow undermined democracy and would feed radicalism.

Iraq

Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki expressed support for the Egyptian people's choices and congratulated Egypt's interim president, a spokesman said. The spokesman, Ali al-Moussawi, added that Iraq is "looking forward to boosting bilateral relations" and is "certain that the new president will move on with the new plan in holding elections and safeguarding national reconciliation".

Syria

Bashar al-Assad on Wednesday praised Egypt's protests against their leader and said his overthrow by the military means the end of "political Islam". Assad, who is seeking to crush a revolt against his own rule, said Egyptians have discovered the "lies" of the Muslim Brotherhood. He spoke in an interview with the state-run Al-Thawra newspaper.

"What is happening in Egypt is the fall of so-called political Islam," Assad said. "This is the fate of anyone in the world who tries to use religion for political or factional interests."

United Arab Emirates

The UAE welcomed the change in Egypt, according to state news agency WAM, and praised the Egyptian armed forces.

"His Highness Abdullah bin Zayed al-Nahayan, the foreign minister of the UAE, expressed his full confidence that the great people of Egypt are able to cross these difficult moments that Egypt is going through," WAM said in a statement.

"Sheikh Abdullah said that the great Egyptian army was able to prove again that they are the fence of Egypt and that they are the protector and strong shield that guarantee Egypt will remain a state of institutions and law," it added.

Qatar

Qatar's new emir congratulated Egypt's Adli Mansour after he was sworn in as an interim leader. Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani, "sent a cable of congratulations" following the swearing in.
The foreign ministry said: "Qatar will continue to respect the will of Egypt and its people across the spectrum," the source said. Qatar was alone among Gulf Arab states in celebrating the 2011 Arab Spring revolt that toppled former president Hosni Mubarak.

United Kingdom
The UK urged for calm in Egypt, but stopped short of calling the military intervention a coup.
"The situation is clearly dangerous and we call on all sides to show restraint and avoid violence," said Foreign Secretary William Hague. "The United Kingdom does not support military intervention as a way to resolve disputes in a democratic system."

The UK called on all parties to move forward and "show the leadership and vision needed to restore and renew Egypt's democratic transition".

"It is vital for them to respond to the strong desire of the Egyptian people for faster economic and political progress for their country," stressed Hague.

This must involve early and fair elections and civilian-led government, he said.

United States

The US State Department expressed concern over the military intervention.

The US ordered the mandatory evacuation of its embassy in Cairo, just hours after the army deposed Morsi. A later travel advisory confirmed that "the Department of State ordered the departure of non-emergency US government personnel and family members from Egypt due to the ongoing political and social unrest."

US President Barack Obama released a statement saying he was deeply concerned by the decision by Egyptian military to depose Morsi, and called for a swift return to civilian government.
"No transition to democracy comes without difficulty, but in the end it must stay true to the will of the people. An honest, capable and representative government is what ordinary Egyptians seek and what they deserve," Obama said.
"The long-standing partnership between the United States and Egypt is based on shared interests and values, and we will continue to work with the Egyptian people to ensure that Egypt’s transition to democracy succeeds.”
However, the US also stopped short of calling the military intervention a coup.
Al Jazeera’s Patty Culhane, reporting from Washington, noted that any country involved in a coup was not entitled to aid from the US.
Germany
Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle said the military intervention was "a major setback for democracy in Egypt" and called for "dialogue and political compromise".
"This is a major setback for democracy in Egypt," Westerwelle said during a visit to Athens. "It is urgent that Egypt return as quickly as possible to the constitutional order... there is a real danger that the democratic transition in Egypt will be seriously damaged."
"We call on all sides to renounce violence. We will watch developments in Egypt very closely. And then make our political decisions.
"Political detentions and a political wave of repression must be avoided at all cost. Now this is about returning to the path of democratic order."
France
French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius said Paris took note that elections had been announced in Egypt following a transition period after the army ousted president Mohamed Morsi.
"In a situation that has worsened seriously and with extreme tension in Egypt, new elections have finally been announced, after a transition period."
France hoped a timetable would be drawn up respecting "civil peace, pluralism, individual liberties and the achievements of the democratic transition, so that the Egyptian people can freely choose their leaders and their future", he added.

15 comments:

  1. What's not to like? I don't see how this could have turned out any better.

    Islamist ideology in general and the MB in particular have been humiliated in the most extreme way: by own-goal epic failure.

    Morsi-the-elected-President pursued his rush to dictatorship with comical alacrity. Cairo was set to become Kandahar on the Nile. Starving, illiterate and sending out jihadis to wreak havoc. Almost the entire population rose up against the MB.

    The Brothers could have held out the promise of salvation as long as they never held power. The Egyptians have been inoculated against Islamism as Anbar in Iraq was: by the replacement of Islamist fantasy with the reality of seventh-century nutbags holding the sword overhead.

    As for the Western lip service to democracy: a Republic cannot salute a coup without undermining its own legitimacy. That's true of any Republic - American, French, whatever. Table-stakes. Actions speak louder. Dogs bark, caravan moves on. The Army won't stay in power in Egypt; it will damage its own interests and it's too smart for that.

    The western world aimed for irrelevance in Egypt and hit the mark. The debate was between Turkey/Qatar on one side and KSA and the rest of the Gulf on the other. Qatar lost. The Brothers were too much of a wildcard for the Kingdom. And nobody else would step up and feed Egypt (see Spengler in PJM).

    The fun part will be forming the new secular corporatists crony oligarchy. It'll happen - nine to 18 months tops. A new President, moar aid, laser shows at the Pyramids, twitter feeds crammed full of Instagramed babes on camels. Good times.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Living in the Arabic community that I do, I've heard a fair amount of opinions about various governmental forms...and I have not heard one, not even one, expressed that favored political religion or political religious government. These are not secular people, quite the opposite in most cases, but they simply do not wish to be "ruled" by clergy. They wish religion to be private. Anyone wonder why I gag when I hear idiots like Terry Jones claim my little town is under Sharia Law?

      Delete
    2. I thought "why is the Monty Python guy commenting on Detroit?"

      So I googled and found the Jones you are talking about...the Quran burner.

      Delete
    3. Yes, pseudo-Pastor Jones is also the personal confidential stooge of former Sec of Defense Gates, and Generals Petraeus and Dempsey. He be important man, sho'nuff is he be.

      Delete
  2. What strikes me as the most unusual comment is from Bashar Al-Assad, who said what I believe should be coming from the western governments.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The enemy of my enemy may not be my friend, but he'll typically sound like... my kinda guy! ;)

      Delete
    2. lewy, excellent analysis, as always, and spot on. DWT, right on as well.

      Delete
  3. Meanwhile Israel is keeping officially silent while being privately happy although there is concern that the US will cut off aid to Egypt, which might bring about the end of the peace treaty between Israel and Egypt. (h/t Israel Matzav)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi annie, I wondered why Israel's reaction wasn't there but then I considered the source. I saw the article you are linking and think Netanyahu made the right decision.

      Delete
  4. By the way I just tried commenting using my iPad and I gave up. I had tow rite the comment in "notes" (because the html signs wouldn't type), but even when I copied the note, I couldn't log in either with google or with wordpress.

    So I'm afraid for the next week I won't be able to comment because I'm going on holiday with my iPad. And my husband of course (minor detail. :) ). Unless one of you (cough cough Lewy cough)

    I hope I'll be able to blog at my own blog with the iPad. I've scheduled a couple of posts for now. Otherwise it'll be a bit quiet.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi annie, sorry about the iPad troubles - I can't help you figure it out definitively because I don't have an iPad.

      But - a couple ideas:

      - this person seems to have the same kinda trouble but got blogger to work ok in a different browser (Opera - which you can install on iPad, apparently). http://www.johnlarge.co.uk/2013/01/26/problems-posting-comments-on-blogger-from-ios-ipad-safari-and-chrome/

      - Blogger has a dedicated native app for iOS: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/blogger/id459407288?mt=8 - may be worth a shot.

      - Since you're on Wordpress with your own blog, you might want to check out the Wordpress native iOS app: http://ios.wordpress.org/

      Hope you get it all working! People mostly love their iPads; me, I like my keyboards...

      Delete
    2. Thanks for your speedy reply Lewy. I'm going to try and install the blogger app for iOS.

      I already have a Wordpress app but it wasn't open when I tried to comment.

      I do love my iPad but it's not really suited to me when I need to type a lot because I touch type and you can't do that on a virtual keyboard. I bought a bluetooth keyboard (2 in fact) and both were useless. Perhaps there are newer versions out there, but I'll wait until I get a newer iPad one of these days. Or perhaps a non-iOS tablet to which I can attach a real keyboard by a cable (if such a tablet exists).

      Delete
  5. Mildly off topic, but still related to the situation in Egypt:

    This is what combat is like, you can die even if you are a civilian just caught up in it... The video is erie, and deja vu.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have no idea how much actual danger that soldier was in... turns out the building wasn't stormed... would it have been if those soldiers hadn't shot people in the crowd? Maybe. Maybe that cameraman would have ended up filming the soldier being thrown off the roof, the way the brother's did to that kid a few days ago.

      Delete
    2. lewy ... you have deftly defined why it is called "the fog of war." My own orientation was as the cameraman, and the sensation felt when you realize someone is really trying to kill you. Specifically you. Every moral or ethical value you've ever had frequently evaporates in that instant.

      From the soldier's side of things, the camera man was using a telephoto lens on what appears to be a Canon DSLR. That can look a lot like a weapon to someone who has it pointed at himself...so a reaction occurs.

      The distinction of whether the building was actually stormed or not is irrelevant, really ... it is the potential for that event that motivates the soldiers on the roof...just as journalistic curiosity motivate the cameraman. Don't take a camera to a gun fight is the moral.

      Delete